Sunrise seen from inside the elf church
Last December 22, the Associated Press posted a story titled "Iceland's Hidden Elves Delay Road Project." It discussed how protests in Iceland had temporarily halted construction of a road through the G'algahraun lava field on the 'Alftanes peninsula - an area that was declared officially protected in 2009 - until the country's supreme court could rule on the case. The story downplayed the fact that environmentalists had been publicly battling the project since its inception. Instead, it focused almost exclusively on the idea that "elf advocates" was leading the protests because the construction was invading an area inhabited by elves and containing an elf church.
The Associated Press item was picked up and reposted by news agencies around the world, with unfortunate results. Here in Chicago, WGN-TV News used images of the cartoon Keebler Elves to illustrate their giggly coverage of the story. National Public Radio's website repackaged the AP article as "Highway In Iceland May Be Sidetracked By Elves" (it seems that we're now capitalizing prepositions) and illustrated it with an image of Liv Tyler as Arwen from "The Lord of the Rings". Apparently, they're following the lead of Public Radio International, who used a photo of someone dressed up as Marvel's movie version of Thor to illustrate a story on the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs finally allowing Thor's hammer as a religious symbol on government grave markers.
For news agencies the world over, the AP item was just too cute to pass up. Who wouldn't want to tell the story of a simple island folk and their quaint belief in invisible beings? It's much easier than doing nasty time-consuming things like researching and interviewing sources. It's also much easier than the bothersome chore of learning about minority faith traditions and treating them with the same respect as popular religions.
"
Altar of the holy place of the elves
Icelandic media immediately challenged the reporting of Jenna Gottlieb, the author of the Associated Press news item. The Reykjav'ik Grapevine" ran a story declaring "Environmentalists Not Elf Lobby," pointing out that they and other Icelandic news outlets had been covering the environmental protests for months - and that Ms. Gottlieb had created an article by "cobbling together quotes from notable figures." Colleagues of mine in Iceland told me that, for instance, Gottlieb's quotes from University of Iceland's Prof. Terry Gunnell were "old and taken out of context." In the United States, "The Wire" ran a story summarizing the response: "Iceland's 'Elf Lobby' Isn't Real, According to Icelanders."
The AP story quoted two sentences about elves from Iceland's Ragnhildur J'onsd'ottir and referred to her as "a self-proclaimed 'seer.'" This was pounced on by writers who struck out against Gottlieb's article. "Icelandic Review Online" called Ragnhildur her a "self-confessed elf believer" in an article asking "How Stupid are the Icelandic People? The Wire" singled her out for ridicule in their coverage without bothering to mention her name; they simply and nastily wrote of "loony elf 'seers' trying to stop construction of a road being built."
All of this is a bit strange. The fundamental premise of the original AP story is that "elf advocates have joined forces with environmentalists to urge the Icelandic Road and Coastal Commission and local authorities to abandon a highway project building a direct route from the Alftanes peninsula." However, Gottlieb does not quote any "elf advocate" involved in the protest - except for the two sentences from Ragnhildur.
In its response, "Icelandic Review Online" simply states, "The story is false" - but didn't seem to have bothered contacting Ragnhildur for her input. "The Wire", while criticizing Gottlieb's journalistic methods, shows no sign that it conducted a single interview of its own; the piece was written by "cobbling together quotes" just as much as the AP story was. "The Reykjav'ik Grapevine" - the originator of the "cobbling together" accusation - likewise created its response by sticking together existing quotes (including a Facebook status update) instead of doing any original interviews.
Where are Gottlieb's interviews with others in the supposed group of "elf advocates"? Was the entire premise of the story built on a two-sentence interview with Ragnhildur? Why didn't any of the writers criticizing the AP piece bother to interview Ragnhildur for their own stories? Would the Associated Press have identified a Catholic priest involved in the protest as "a self-proclaimed 'holy man'"? Would "Icelandic Review Online" refer to a Jewish demonstrator as a "self-confessed Yahweh believer"? Would "The Wire" refer to a Muslim protestor as "loony" and put "imam" in sarcastic quotation marks?
"
A light-elf in the G'algahraun lava field
I have corresponded with Ragnhildur for several years, and I met her in at Thingvellir in Iceland after participating in the sumars'olst"odubl'ot" (summer solstice ceremony) of the 'Asatr'uarf'elagid ("AEsir Faith Fellowship") in 2010. As Iceland's leading elf specialist, she leads elf walks through 'Alfagardurinn ("elf garden") in Hafnarfj"ordur and creates original art based on her contact with the elves. I wrote about her public work when covering a 2012 "Elf Kerfuffle in Iceland" that also involved road construction and elf habitats.
Back in December, I thought that it might be a good idea if someone actually asked Raghnhildur what she thought of the coverage. I emailed her a link to the Associated Press story and congratulated her on the successful halting of the construction project. Here is her reply:
December 25, 2013
Hello and thank you, Karl Erik.
Yes, it is a wonderful story, but I am so sorry to say that it is not completely true. The Road Administration is still working on the road. They are halfway through the lava field with the road, but the elf church and their holy area is still in place.
The elves (with me as their speaker in the human world) have come to an agreement with the Road Administration and Gardabaer's mayor to move a known elf church called 'Ofeigskirkja a few meters out of the way of the road into a safe place next to a very sacred place to the elves. The humans will make sure nothing of this will be damaged and it will be marked as an elf holy area.
I know it will be too hard for the humans in charge to stop the road from being made, but they are at least willing to help the elves now as they can, to make the best of the situation as it is. I am very happy that the mayor and the Road Administration are willing to do this now; it is a good step. This project of moving the 'Ofeigskirkja is a very large project, plus making sure the whole area is safe and protected from then on. I am sure you will hear about that when it happens.
Best elf wishes to you and thank your interest. Thank you for all you are doing.
- RagnhildurI told her that I would like to post her letter, and she was gracious enough to agree. The next day, however, she wrote:
December 26, 2013 Dear Karl, I will have to ask you something. I am so sorry, but something came up, and it would be better to wait a little bit before announcing it. I need some time before I can talk about the protection of the elf church. I am really sorry. But I can say, "I have a good reason to believe the holy place of the elves will be saved and protected."Six weeks later, Ragnhildur wrote again:
February 7, 2014Hello Karl, I promised to tell you about the protection in the G'algahraun lava field. I have now met again with Magn'us from the Road Administration and some of the men working on the road. They showed me drawings with changes of the road where it goes by the side of the elf church (holy place). They are going to move one known elf church (more like a chapel) out of the way of the road. It will be placed a few meters away, right beside the main holy place that we call Elf Church. One more elf rock called Graenh'oll (Green Hill) is also being saved.
The road is going to be four meters narrower while passing this area of three rocks. It will be fenced off from the road, and pathways will be leading to the area from another direction. The road being narrower means that the road itself is the same width but the area beside the road [i.e., the shoulder] is made narrower.
Anyway, wanted to tell you this. Thank you for your interest in this, Karl.
Best wishes,
RagnhildurShe sent another update this week:
February 25, 2014
I have heard from the man Magn'us at Vegagerdi (Road Administration). They are going to move the 'Ofeigskirkja in the middle of March. This rock called 'Ofeigskirkja - a kind of an elf chapel - is in the middle of the road they are making. They will move it out of the way to a nearby, almost flat lava. It is right next to the main elf church or holy place.
That means the two holy places - high energy places - will both be saved and protected there, next to each other. There is the third rock, known as Graenh'oll; it is very close also.Finally, she was kind enough to send additional photographs of the area with detailed explanations.
February 26, 2014 Hello Karl, I am sending you two photos from the sacred place in G'algahraun lava field.
This first one shows the new road. In front to the left is 'Ofeigskirkja. It is an "elf chapel," so to speak. The elves told me humans and elves said a prayer there before or while going through the rough lava field. This big rock is in the middle of the new road, but the Road Administration and the mayor of Gardabaer are making changes. They will move this rock over the road where you see the dog. The main elf church is in the back to the right, with a flag on top.The second photo shows the main elf church or holy place. This beautiful place is so very special and has great, very high energy. The beings there tell me it has been a holy place for them for thousands of years, since long before humans arrived here - and they will protect it. 'Ofeigskirkja will be put down right next to this one. The road is narrower where it goes past this area. They will fence it off from the road and put up signs to say what it is. If the elves had done nothing, this whole area would have been destroyed.I hope this helps. Next month they will move 'Ofeigskirkja and we will probably have something in the news then, at least. I will let you know and I will post about it on Facebook. Best wishes for you and thank you for your interest.
- RagnhildurThere you have it, gentle readers. Make up your own minds about the original story, the critiques, the letters and the photographs. I simply thought that the professional journalists on both sides of the issue could use a bit of reminding about original research, speaking to sources and following up on a story as it develops "after" the initial AP report. My faith in modern journalism keeps getting lower as, for example, I repeatedly catch reporters in the mainstream media who are writing articles by literally cutting and pasting from Wikipedia articles.
I'm not sure if this is a problem that saturates all areas of journalism today, or if it's localized to religion reporting. Journalists who cover the religion beat seem particularly perplexed when confronted with any belief systems outside the Abrahamic mainstream. I would love to see (to use a tired but apt phrase) fair and balanced coverage of minority faith traditions, but it's sometimes hard to keep my hopes up - especially when we have shoddy reporting like that surrounding this particular story.
