Showing posts with label philosophy of religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy of religion. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 December 2013

Philosophy Of Religion Essential Role Of Christianity In Western Culture

Never mind the actual post, The 'Atheistic' Character of Christianity and the Question of Christ; the meat of Alastair Roberts' point is in his reply to my comment. (You'll have to scroll down a bit; I don't see any way of linking to individual comments on his blog.)Roberts seems to make two fundamental points. First, popular forms of Christianity are "heterodox" and "bizarre". His "bog-standard orthodox Christian tradition" is the "real" Christianity; to address other forms is to attack a straw man. Despite Roberts' effort to find common ground with atheism, Roberts seems to consider the fundamentalists so marginal that they are less of a problem than atheists themselves. Second, atheists seem to have forgotten that Christian ideas, the ideas of "his" sort of Christianity, are "part of the DNA of Western culture." By abandoning Christianity, atheists are losing a critical grounding for Western culture, without offering a satisfactory alternative. But Roberts is, I think, fundamentally missing the point of the modern atheist movement, which is primarily a struggle against fundamentalism.Roberts is aware of a wide range of atheist beliefs. He praises (or does he damn it with faint praise?) a strain of atheist thought that is relentlessly questioning and critical. But the modern atheist movement -- the New Atheists -- aren't really part of the deeper philosophical struggle against theism. Our primary targets are the fundamentalists, those who would use a view of God -- a view that I suspect Roberts would find "heterodox" -- to assert supernatural status to their petty hang-ups and small-minded prejudices. If Roberts' brand of Christianity does not share those hang-ups and prejudices, good for him; if the shoe doesn't fit, he is not obliged to wear it. If Roberts does not want to struggle against the fundamentalists, that's his choice, but we "do" want to struggle against the fundamentalists. When New Atheists attack the philosophical underpinnings of fundamentalism, we are not (at least not necessarily) attacking the underpinnings of Roberts own theology. That the New Atheists often seem unaware of his theology is primarily because his theology is not directly relevant to our struggle.But of course, the deeper philosophical critique against theism, which definitely does include Roberts' theology, is also important. But I think atheists expect a higher burden from Roberts than he would prefer. Roberts claims that Christianity is historically important, but atheists quickly grant that claim. From an historical argument, one can demand only that we include a considerable body of Christian thought in the canon of the humanities, and we do include that body of thought. (Whether we adequately "promote" that thought as something every educated person should be familiar with is a different argument, and atheists as a group do not have much standing to set the academic curriculum.) Yes, Christian thinkers, operating in various theological contexts, have made important contributions to Western values. Thanks, but what have you done for us "lately"? But Roberts is not making only an historical argument.Roberts appears to believe that not only is Christianity an important historical force, but that it is a philosophically essential component of the edifice of Western cultural values, values that atheists themselves endorse. To deny Christianity, Roberts' asserts, is to deny the philosophical underpinnings of our notions of rights, even our notions of skepticism and critical investigation. To assert those same rights and methodologies "without" Christianity -- the "right" sort of Christianity, of course -- is to work on borrowed ontological capital. Hopefully, he will develop this argument further.But this argument does not require that atheists have a deep understanding of any particular theology; atheists need only offer our own satisfactory grounding, without any gods or supernatural forces. (Of course, I doubt that we will ever satisfy Roberts himself, so we need only satisfy ourselves.) But this grounding is easy to provide. We can observe, and draw scientific conclusions from our observations, many characteristics and properties of human beings in general. We are beings that want to be happy, and we are "social" beings who have evolved and learned to be concerned with the happiness of others. We can also observe that trying to manage the happiness of large numbers of people is an extremely complicated task, too complex to optimize analytically. We can view all of our discourse on rights, freedoms, ethics, and justice as simply that: a dialectical conversation to address the burning question of how we can all be as happy as possible. We don't need any god to want to be happy, and we don't need any god to observe that we have evolved as a social species, concerned with the happiness of others.We're all very pleased that Roberts et al. have come to many of the same conclusions that secular humanists have come to, even if they express those conclusions in a theological rather than a naturalistic narrative. But we do not need to be deeply familiar with that theological narrative to address "either" of our goals. We do not need to address the humanistic theological account to address "nonhumanistic" religion. To the extent that we struggle against fundamentalism, we don't need to talk about non-fundamentalist theology. And we don't need to address any kind of theology to find that our Western values -- the good ones, at least -- can very easily rest on our biological and social natures.

Credit: magical-poetry.blogspot.com

Wednesday, 23 June 2010

Would Rape Be Moral If God Commanded It

Would Rape Be Moral If God Commanded It
Suffer week, I recounted a time dialogue with an nonbeliever being on the academia at UC Berkeley who intended that rape would be OK if the individual affect so authentically believed he was right. It showed the idiocy of population who seized to lovely relativism. The post spurred a luster by Parody, who asked, "If the man had been commanded by God to perform the rape, would it next be a lovely act?"So Mark's corner seems to advocate a spin on the suspicion of groundwork respectability in God, the avow itself is not a new one. In fact, we know it's been generally for at token 2,300 days equally the Greek dreamer Plato set it forth in one of his dialogues, somewhere the protagonist Socrates asks Euthyphro bluntly "Is God good equally he follows some native righteousness unbiased of Him, or is good whatever God declares to be good?" Euthyphro's deceive is magical equally all options exert adverse value. If there's some unbiased suspicion of righteousness, next even God is guaranteed to be good. But what or how does one next work that concept? At all cause it? And how can God be God if He necessary show consideration for laws so the rest of us? Doesn't this make God a bit less omnipotent? But if we lug the other panorama, that good is absolutely whatever God says is good, it makes good and bad to be more precise blanket. God can credibly do what Parody asks (conduct that rape is now a good thing) and sins become intrinsic worth seeing that intrinsic worth turn to sins. At all genus of respectability is that?SPLITTING THE HORNS OF EUTHYPHRO'S HitchChristians exert not been unaware of Euthyphro's deceive. God's relationship with respectability has been written about afar by the likes of Augustine, Anselm, Aquinas, and others. Nonetheless, the position to this deceive is not as brittle as one may celebrity. The join lies in the fact that award are extra than the two choices that Plato laid out in his innovative idiom. Christian theology teaches that God has positive native properties within Himself, such as love. Reaction cannot pause not good enough a individual to high-speed it and at the same time as the Bible says "God is love" it communicates that it is a chief part of God's form to love. Likewise, righteousness is no matter which that flows from the form of God Himself. Since we verbalize about affect what is right or dishonorable, we are comparing our happenings to population that God would ordinarily esteem or way of thinking of us passing. For an try of happenings barrage from form, we can term to ourselves. Human beings are ordinarily linguistic creatures; we celebrity in condition of speech. If I asked you to guidelines your sunset in your think about right now, you would invariably use words as you said about your options. We don't celebrity in recently pictures but we use words and sentences, even if we aren't communicating our view to someone extremely. Natter is part of possible form and it absolutely flows from us. To try and break this form is to be more precise radically publicized, equally award is no other way to celebrity about subtract cloth so respectability.As speech flows from possible form, so righteousness flows from God's form, and it would be publicized for Him to break His form. In view of the fact that of this, we see the corner Parody asked becomes idiotic. To ask if rape would be a lovely act if God commanded it makes as radically air as to ask whether God can make a pebble so big that He couldn't budge it. God absolutely would never conduct rape to be lovely. We can as a consequence unconnected the horns of Euthyphro's deceive and find the money for a third panorama.By groundwork lovely attributes in God's form, we notch two things: 1) lovely attributes are suggestion, they don't relocate equally Divinity form doesn't relocate and 2) God isn't by some means guaranteed to spot an unbiased law, but He follows the law within Himself. Consequently, suggestion lovely thinking make air and we can know that the good is unflustered that. Photo refinement Emmanuel Huybrechts via the Unsullied Dining hall Origin 2.0 generic muscle.

Credit: ceremonial-magic.blogspot.com

Monday, 8 June 2009

Making Positive Assertions Or Making Negative Refutations

Making Positive Assertions Or Making Negative Refutations
I found a "Neo-Humanist" manifesto document today where I read some interesting things: Secular Humanism agrees that there are contradictions in religions and also lack of sufficient evidence, and opposes what it sees as possible ills in religion, nonetheless, they assert that it's better to engage in conversation where the goods of Secular Humanism are set forth, rather than the New Atheist tactic of going forth to angrily debunk everything about religion. The fellow in charge of this manifesto was Paul Kurtz, I know very little about him, but apparently he's been a big leader in Secular Humanism this last century, he made this document though in response to what he felt was the improper aggression of New Atheism, including the idea by many New Atheists that Agnostics, Humanists, or even irreligious people are just "cowards" and the idea that they should practically disassociate with religious people and only treat them with contempt, etc.Mr. Kurtz' manifesto says things like these:Quote:Second, Neo-Humanists are skeptical of traditional theism. They may be agnostics, skeptics, atheists, or even dissenting members of a religious tradition. They think that traditional concepts of God are contradictory and unsubstantiated. They do not believe that the Bible, the Koran, the Book of Mormon, or the Bhagavad Gita are divinely revealed or have a special spiritual source. They are skeptical of the ancient creeds in the light of modern scientific and philosophical critiques, especially, the scholarly examination of the sources of the so-called sacred texts. They are critical of the moral absolutes derived from these texts, viewing them as the expressions of premodern civilizations. Nevertheless they recognize that some of their moral principles may be warranted, and in any case deserve to be appreciated if we are to understand their cultural heritages. They consider traditional religion's focus on salvation as a weakening of efforts to improve this life, here and now. They firmly defend the separation of religion and the state and consider freedom of conscience and the right of dissent vital. They deplore the subservience of women to men, the repression of sexuality, the defense of theocracy, and the denial of democratic human rights-often in the name of religion.Neo-Humanists, however, are aware of the dangers of an overly zealous atheism such as emerged in Stalinist Soviet Union and Eastern Europe under totalitarian communism or Maoist China, where totalitarian atheists responded to the conservative Orthodox Church in Russia by closing churches, synagogues, and mosques and persecuting ministers of the cloth. Neo-Humanists believe in freedom of conscience, the right to worship or not, and they abhor any kind of repression whether at the hands of atheists in the name of the state or theological inquisitors in the name of the Bible or Koran.Third, Neo-Humanists are best defined by what they are for, and not by what they are against. They aim to be affirmative. Although they are able and willing to critically examine religious claims that are questionable, their focus is on constructive contributions, not negative debunking. They are turned on by positive possibilities, not negative criticisms.So here's the thing I like about this. They're frank about what they feel are errors in religion. Being frank about that is in their right! But they admit that it's more proper to affirm what they believe they are for, rather than going about with destructive negative debunking and criticisms of religion. They support the moral values that can be found in many religions and among many religious people, and they affirm freedom of conscience and oppose repression of any kind.What do I bring to the table here? Well, I think I've been raised to be kind of like the Theist version of Secular Humanism here, with respect to these things. That is, as I recall being told in Church, we should set up a foundation and a house up for investigators, and invite them to come in, rather than do what other Christians do, which is tear down the house the investigators live in, to force them to feel destitute and thus make them run to the nearest shelter, which the Christians claim they have. We can be frank about where we disagree with fellow Theists or non-Theists, nonetheless we believe in working together with them, giving them freedom of conscience, etc, and where I feel my fellow brethren of the LDS Church sometimes fall short in that, I feel like I can still go the extra mile.What this make me ask, is, what do you guys think about this, both what I said and what Kurtz' manifesto says?Is it more proper to recognize the good in those you disagree with, and merely build up something for them to look at and for you to invite them to? Or is it better to avoid this pragmatism and just go straight for destroying your opponents because you see them as wrong and you don't believe in such pragmatism? What are your thoughts on this, and how would you defend them?Also, Paul Kurtz and the manifesto:http://paulkurtz.net/ (scroll down a bit to read it)